• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Doyle APC

Nationwide Mass Tort Lawyers

  • About
  • Practice Areas
    • Social Media Addiction
    • Medical Devices & Drugs
    • Class Actions
  • Cases
    • Social Media Addiction
    • Covidien Hernia Mesh
    • Bard Hernia Mesh
    • Bard PowerPort
  • News
  • Contact

Retired Judge Starts Ruling on Meta’s Withheld Documents

November 20, 2026

A retired judge reviewing documents Meta withheld from the plaintiffs in the social media addiction lawsuits has issued her first rulings, and Meta is challenging only a small number of them. In two reports filed in the federal court in Oakland, California, on November 11 and November 17, special master Suzanne H. Segal ruled on Meta’s privilege claims over 952 documents. Meta has objected to her rulings on 14 of them.

Why a Judge Is Reviewing Meta’s Documents

In a lawsuit, each side must share relevant evidence. A company may hold back confidential conversations with its lawyers (attorney-client privilege) and material prepared by or for its lawyers because of expected lawsuits (work product). Families and school districts suing Meta say the company used those labels far too broadly to keep its internal research about teens out of the cases. Meta says it made its privilege calls in good faith.

Chief Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers oversees the federal multidistrict litigation, or MDL, where one judge handles thousands of similar lawsuits before trial. She ordered Meta to re-review key documents, and on October 16 she appointed a special master, a neutral reviewer who decides disputes for the court, subject to appeal to the judge. On October 20 she approved the rules for a broader re-review, which Meta must finish by December 30.

What the First Rulings Show

The first group included 751 documents. In objections filed November 13, Meta said that while it had good-faith grounds for the claims the special master overruled, the vast majority involved small redactions of “lawyer call-outs” that were not significant, and it would not challenge them. It objected to the rulings on 12 documents, or nine once duplicates are removed.

Five of those documents, or two once duplicates are removed, are compilations of Meta’s research on young users. Meta says they were created in September 2021, after former employee Frances Haugen leaked internal research to The Wall Street Journal, to help its lawyers prepare for expected lawsuits. In a November 16 response, the plaintiffs argued that briefing executives on the company’s own research “is a business function, not preparation for litigation,” and asked the special master to overrule each objection.

The second group included 201 documents. On November 18, Meta objected to the rulings on two: a June 2022 chat discussing Meta’s legal duty to report to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, and a document on “cool down” options for a Facebook feature called Feed Pause.

Thousands More Documents Released

Meta told the court in a November 6 filing that on November 9 it would turn over in full about 10,000 documents it had withheld entirely and remove the redactions from about 60,000 others. Meta said it found them largely with keyword searches and AI-assisted review, and that it had not determined they were wrongly withheld but chose to produce them given the limited time before trial and the court’s recent guidance on privilege.

The plaintiffs told the court that Meta withdrew or narrowed its privilege claims on 79% of 1,000 documents the plaintiffs selected and 90% of a first batch of 16,700 documents Meta selected. Meta responded that it has withheld less than 2% and redacted less than 5% of responsive documents, and that it has produced more than 2.6 million documents.

What Comes Next

The plaintiffs have separately asked the judge to sanction Meta over its privilege claims, to be heard December 14. They want to use the released documents at upcoming trials. The next federal trials, school district cases brought by Tucson Unified School District in Arizona and Charleston County School District in South Carolina, are scheduled to begin February 8, 2027. In the California state court cases in Los Angeles, the next trial of young people’s injury claims is currently set for March 16, 2027.

The privilege fight does not decide any family’s claim. The lawsuits allege that Meta knew from its own research that its services harmed young users. As of November 2, 4,309 actions were pending in the federal MDL against Meta, TikTok, Snap and YouTube, according to the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation.

Doyle APC handles social media addiction claims nationwide together with experienced co-counsel.

Free Case Review →

If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988 to reach the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline.

Footer

San Diego Office

Doyle APC
550 W B St, 4th Floor
San Diego, CA 92101
Phone: (619) 736-0000
Fax: (619) 736-1111

© 2026 DOYLE APC. All rights reserved.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact

This site is designed to be accessible and usable by people with and without disabilities. Please contact us if you experience an accessibility or usability issue. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Attorney advertising.